The Calling Of Ella McFarland: The Women of Rock Creek – Book 1

Reviewed by: Katherine Hiegel, a professional writing major at Taylor University in Upland, IN

Ministry Title:

Church: Hyperlink the church website here.



Author: Linda Brooks Davis

Publisher: Mountainview Press

Publication Date: November 20, 2015

FormatPrint Book

Length: 376 pages


Farm dweller and aspiring schoolteacher Ella McFarland finds her life taking a different turn when a needy neighborhood girl, Lily, comes under her care. After much soul-searching and prayer, Ella gives up her dream of teaching at a prestigious school and decides to start her own school for disadvantaged girls. But she must contend not only with her own family’s expectations of a woman’s place, but also with Frank, an unhappy figure from her past, and Walter, Lily’s abusive father. Along the way, she finds herself at odds with her spoiled younger sister, Viola, and struggles to balance her vocational call with a growing attraction to a handsome admirer.

Davis’s dialogue and historical setting are fairly authentic, and her meaty descriptions give the reader a good sense of place, time, and detail. However, sentences are so weighed down with adjectives, adverbs, modifiers, and extraneous anecdotes that sometimes there’s too much detail. The content is clean, though there is a general description of an attempted rape, and several incidents of physical abuse and drunkenness. Davis’s work is filled with heartfelt prayer and references to Scripture, but the characters’ tidy “sanitized” Christianity may fail to ring true to readers. Characters are adequately well rounded, but beware of a rather clichéd love interest and a cheesy romance that takes place. Near the end, certain characters’ changes of heart seem too sudden and straightforward to be credible.


Rating (1 to 5)

3 stars

Suggested Audience

Primarily Christian women 18 and older who enjoy historical romance novels

Christian Impact


Use this space to give a one line bio of the reviewer

Interested in reviewing a book, movie, album, or other type of media for our website? We would love to hear from you! Find out more about how to submit media reviews.

The Calling of Ella McFarland (Women of Rock Creek #1)

About ECLA Web Team

The Evangelical Church Library Association, founded in 1970, is a fellowship of Christian churches, schools, and individuals. This account is managed by the ECLA Web Team.

No comments yet... Be the first to leave a reply!

Leave a Reply